Vic Firth · American Classic
Vic Firth American Classic 5A Barrel Tip
The Vic Firth 5ABRL is a hickory drumstick measuring 16 inches by .565 inches with a barrel wood tip and a medium taper. It is the standard 5A shaft with the teardrop bead replaced by a barrel, which narrows the contact patch and tightens the cymbal sound.
One variable changed
The shaft is a 5A: 16 inches, .565 inches, medium taper, hickory. Everything that makes the best-selling stick in the world feel the way it does is untouched.
What changes is the bead. A teardrop is a smooth curved swell; a barrel is closer to a short cylinder with flattened ends. Swap one for the other and the shaft still feels identical while the cymbals do something noticeably different.
That makes this a rare thing in a stick catalogue: a genuine controlled experiment you can run yourself for the price of a pair of sticks.
What the barrel actually does here
Vic Firth’s Neil Larrivee has said the barrel versions were drawn individually rather than scaled from one master shape, because a bead that suits a 5A does not suit a 5B.
On this stick the barrel is proportionally small, and the reduced surface area gives a more focused cymbal sound — more of a defined point, less spread. Against the standard 5A’s teardrop you get clarity where the original gives warmth.
The flat crown also makes the sound more consistent across stroke angles. A cylinder presents roughly the same profile however it lands, which is why barrel tips are popular with session players: a take does not change character as the hand tires.
Which one to buy
If you like a 5A and want the ride pattern to sit further forward in a mix, this is the version to take. If you like a 5A because the ride sounds warm and broad, stay on the teardrop — this is a sideways move, not an upgrade.
A note on the source link
Vic Firth’s own product URLs for the two barrel-tip models are transposed: the page titled “5A
Barrel Tip”, carrying the 5ABRL model number and the .565-inch specification, sits at the address
ending 5b-w-barrel-tip. The source cited above is that page — the title, model number and
dimensions all agree with this record, and only the address does not.
Specifications
Sources
Numbered footnotes in the spec table point here.
- 1Tier 1 · Primarymanufacturer spec