How we source
A reference is only worth as much as its sourcing. This page says exactly what our marks mean, so you can decide how much to trust any given number.
Every fact points at a source
There is no unattributed specification anywhere on this site. Each row in a spec table carries a link to the source it came from and a status mark. If a value has no source, it says so rather than quietly appearing as fact.
What the marks mean
- Verified — the value came from the cited source and has been checked against it. This is not a claim that the source is correct, only that we did not invent the number. Read the verification pass below for which rows this is fully true of yet, and which are still catching up.
- Unverified — the value comes from editorial knowledge and is waiting on a source. It is probably right. It is not evidence.
- Contested — credible sources disagree. Both values are shown, with who says what. This happens constantly with vintage drums and specification changes that manufacturers made without announcing them.
Source tiers
| Tier | What it is |
|---|---|
| 1 — Primary | Manufacturer specification pages and catalogues, press releases, our own physical measurements. |
| 2 — High | Established retailer listings that reproduce manufacturer specs, published books with editors, institutional archives. |
| 3 — Secondary | Specialist sites and long-standing collector research. Cited and linked, never copied. |
| 4 — Low | Forum posts, marketplace listings, and our own editorial knowledge. Leads only. Never sufficient on its own. |
The verification pass
For most of this site's life the machine that builds it could not reach the open web. Specs were written from search results that described a manufacturer's page without ever fetching it. So a row marked verified against a tier-1 source meanta manufacturer page was found and summarised — not a manufacturer page was opened and read. That is a weaker claim than the word suggests, and this page used to make the stronger one.
That access opened on 16 September 2026, and a pass to close the gap is underway. It works brand by brand: fetch every cited URL, open each page, and check the value against what the page actually says. Roughly 400 of the 560 cited URLs are now fetched and 108 records have been re-checked against pages someone opened. The rest still carry the weaker claim, and will until the pass reaches them.
It has been worth doing. Four tier-1 URLs turned out to be dead — one of them cited by thirteen records, another by fourteen — and one more answered every request with an empty page while eighteen records cited it. Two specs recorded as contested were not: in both cases the source said to be disagreeing agreed, and the conflict existed only in a summary of it. A shell recorded as "not published" is published, on the maker's own product page. Elsewhere the pass has moved rows the other way, from verified to unverified, because the page turned out not to carry the claim at all.
Where a page states nothing, we say so on the row rather than leaving a clean-looking gap. Several makers — Zildjian and both Istanbuls among them — publish no alloy anywhere on their sites, and those rows now say that in as many words.
Where we are honest about being early
This site is new and small. A large share of current specifications are sourced from tier-2 retailer listings rather than tier-1 manufacturer pages, and some rows are still marked unverified. That is a real limitation, and marking it visibly is better than hiding it behind confident formatting.
Sizes and model numbers are the values most often wrong across the whole industry — including on large retailers' own pages. Where a model number and a stated size conflict in our sources, we follow the model number and note the conflict.
Corrections
If something here is wrong, we want to fix it, and we would rather be corrected than be trusted by default. Corrections are applied to the record and the change is reflected in the "updated" date on the page.
Video
Videos are embedded from YouTube and belong to their creators, who keep the view and the revenue. We do not re-host anyone's video or strip attribution. No YouTube code loads until you press play, so browsing this site does not report you to anyone.
Images and diagrams
The exploded diagrams are our own original artwork. They are free to use elsewhere with a link back — if you teach, take them. We do not republish manufacturer or collector photography without written permission, which is why you will see diagrams here where other sites would show a product photo.