Vic Firth · Symphonic Signature
Vic Firth Symphonic Signature Tim Genis GEN5 Tonal
The Vic Firth GEN5 Tonal is a wood-core timpani mallet on a 14½-inch persimmon handle. Vic Firth describe it as an excellent all-purpose mallet, and it is the softest of the four wood-core Genis models.
Where the wood cores begin
Genis’s seven mallets divide in two. GEN1 to GEN3 have felt cores; GEN5 to GEN8 have wood cores. The GEN5 is the first of the second group and the softest of them.
What a wood core does
The core is the body the outer felt is wrapped around, and whether it compresses decides the character of the attack.
A felt core compresses along with the wrap. However hard the outer layer, the stroke keeps meeting something compliant, so the attack stays cushioned and the sound stays rounded.
A wood core does not compress. The outer felt flattens on impact and then the stroke arrives at something rigid, which produces a definite leading edge. The tone is still there — the felt wrap produced it — but the moment of impact is now audible as an event.
So a wood-core mallet with soft wrap is not the same thing as a felt-core mallet with hard wrap, even if both are described as medium. They are two different sounds, and that is why the range has seven members rather than four.
All-purpose, which is a real claim
Vic Firth’s description — an excellent all-purpose mallet — reads like a hedge and is not. A soft wrap over a rigid core is the combination that covers the most ground: the felt gives enough tone for lyrical writing, the core gives enough definition for rhythmic writing.
If a player carrying the Genis range picks one pair for an unfamiliar programme, this is the pair.
Against the T1
Vic Firth’s standard general mallet, the T1, is turned from a single piece of rock maple — shaft and core together, with no joint. That is a different solution to the same requirement, and arguably a more durable one, since there is no interface that can work loose.
What the GEN5 offers against it is the persimmon handle’s stiffness and a wrap voiced for orchestral rather than all-round use. The T1 is the standard; this is the specialist’s version of it.
Specifications
Sources
Numbered footnotes in the spec table point here.
- 1Tier 1 · Primarymanufacturer spec